Book Review: After Alice by Gregory Maguire

After Alice Gregory Maguire

 

After Alice by Gregory Maguire

The summer day waxes hot in Oxford and young Alice has gone missing. But enough about her. Right now we’re concerned with the plights of Lydia, Alice’s older sister, Ada, the neighbor girl, and Miss Armstrong, Ada’s governess.

The book opens with the squalling of an infant: Ada’s younger brother, and a sudden, pressing need to be out of the house. Running out ahead of her governess, young Ada heads down to see her friend Alice. Encountering Alice’s sister, Lydia, on the road, she is directed to Alice’s regular haunt. Unfortunately for Ada, who requires an iron brace to walk straight, she encounters a rabbit hole instead and promptly tumbles down.

Miss Armstrong is left to search after her charge, becoming more and more worried when it seems that Alice may be missing as well. Dragging a reluctant Lydia along in the search, she is desperate to find the girls before Ada’s or Alice’s fathers learn the girls have gone. Ada, meanwhile, must navigate Wonderland and its strange denizens to find both Alice and her way home.

All this sounds a bit more promising in summary that it was in reality. I’m a fan of Gregory Maguire, Wicked was a fantastic book, and added a huge amount to L. Frank Baum’s classic. We don’t get that same gift here with After Alice. There are no huge revelations about any Wonderland favorites, nor is the real world plot very compelling. Following Ada into Wonderland, we meet many of the same folks that Alice did, but we gain nothing new in the encounter. After a bit, it seems as though we’re ticking off boxes, making sure we’ve said hello to everyone, but not really speaking to them.

Back in Oxford, we follow Lydia and Miss Armstrong as they search for Ada and Alice. This story line largely seems to go nowhere. The two women search halfheartedly, annoy one another, and compete for a gentleman’s attention. Lydia is sharp where Miss Armstrong is a bit insipid, but neither seems very engaged in finding their missing charges, which is the part I had been keen to explore: what pandemonium might erupt in Oxford when not one, but two children go missing? The answer seems to be very, very, very little.

In all, I feel like this is not Maguire’s best work. I’d recommend this for hardcore Maguire fans, and those looking for even a little bit more about Alice and her world. For the more casual reader: you won’t hate this book, but it left little impression on me.

A copy of this book was provided via Goodreads Givaways in exchange for an honest review. After Alice is currently available for purchase.

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s